Tuesday, December 10, 2013

Manifest Destiny and the Mexican American War


At the time of the U.S.-Mexican War (and the height of the popularity of Manifest Destiny), there were some Americans who spoke out against what they regarded as a "war of aggression". However, for the most part, the American public supported the war and the idea of Manifest Destiny itself. Today many historians see things differently.

Think about these two quotes while you watch the video clips:

"We love to indulge in thoughts of the future extent and power of this Republic - because with its increase is the increase of human happiness and liberty. . . . What has miserable, inefficient Mexico - with her superstition, her burlesque upon freedom, her actual tyranny by the few over the many - what has she to do with the great mission of peopling the New World with a noble race? Be it ours, to achieve that mission!"
– Walt Whitman, Editorial, Brooklyn Daily Eagle, July 7, 1846

"This war was an aggressive war in which we attacked a neighbor and however much we won from the war, we do not like to look at the way in which we won it."
– David Pletcher, American Historian, 1998



Consider the mid-19th century view of manifest destiny and the modern-day perspectives of the historians you have read (Pletcher,Velasco-Marquez, Tindall and Shi).

To what extent do you agree with the arguments made by the historians and the contemporary voices of the time (Polk, Grant, Thoreau, Whitman).  In what ways have the interpretations of the Mexican-American War evolved?

In your initial post, use evidence from the readings and videos.  Later, respond to one of your peer's post.  This assignment will be worth 20 points and broken down as follows:

Initial post citing specific evidence from readings/videos                             _____/10 points
Response to peer's post with specific evidence from post/readings/video    _____/10 points

All posts must be time stamped by mid-night on Wednesday!

Thursday, August 22, 2013

Welcome APUSH Class of 2014!

"History is full of really good stories. That's the main reason I got into this racket: I want to make the argument that history is interesting."
~Sarah Vowell

Here we go! A new school year and the beginning of our APUSH journey is about to begin. You can find your summer reading assignment instructions here:

APUSH Summer Reading Assignment

I will collect all summer work on Wednesday, September 4, 2013.  That gives you two weeks to finish your work.  I recommend you watch the C-Span video of Ray Raphael talking about Founding Myths and his suggestions of how we can tell a more accurate US History.


Ray Raphael lecture at College of Holy Cross in Worcester, MA from June, 2013.

Why do we ignore some stories and emphasize others? At 10:43, Ray Raphael asks important questions we all should ask when studying history. What is told and what is left out? Do these myths create harm?

At 18:48, Raphael defines the difference between history and heritage.  Is cultural identity and affirmation important? What might have influenced the choices historians made when they decided to emphasize some of these stories over others?

At 24:46 Raphael suggests ways to deal with these myths. What is your reaction to the different approaches? (Bad Cop/Outrage, Good Cop/Disclaimers, Use of passive Voice, Neutrality by a Asking Questions, Use Better Stories)