Read the articles An Ideal or a Justification? A Conversation With David M. Pletcher Indiana University and A Mexican Viewpoint on the War With the United States by Jesús Velasco-Márquez Instituto Tecnológico Autónomo de México
Think about these two quotes while you watch the video clips:
"We love to indulge in thoughts of the future extent and power of this Republic - because with its increase is the increase of human happiness and liberty. . . . What has miserable, inefficient Mexico - with her superstition, her burlesque upon freedom, her actual tyranny by the few over the many - what has she to do with the great mission of peopling the New World with a noble race? Be it ours, to achieve that mission!"
– Walt Whitman, Editorial, Brooklyn Daily Eagle, July 7, 1846
"This war was an aggressive war in which we attacked a neighbor and however much we won from the war, we do not like to look at the way in which we won it."
– David Pletcher, American Historian, 1998
Consider the mid-19th century view of manifest destiny and the modern-day perspectives of the historians you have read (Pletcher,Velasco-Marquez, Tindall and Shi).
To what extent do you agree with the arguments made by the historians and the contemporary voices of the time (Polk, Grant, Thoreau, Whitman). In what ways have the interpretations of the Mexican-American War evolved?
In your initial post, use evidence from the readings and videos. Later, respond to one of your peer's post. This assignment will be worth 20 points and broken down as follows:
Initial post citing specific evidence from readings/videos _____/10 points
– David Pletcher, American Historian, 1998
Watch the two following clips:
Consider the mid-19th century view of manifest destiny and the modern-day perspectives of the historians you have read (Pletcher,Velasco-Marquez, Tindall and Shi).
To what extent do you agree with the arguments made by the historians and the contemporary voices of the time (Polk, Grant, Thoreau, Whitman). In what ways have the interpretations of the Mexican-American War evolved?
In your initial post, use evidence from the readings and videos. Later, respond to one of your peer's post. This assignment will be worth 20 points and broken down as follows:
Initial post citing specific evidence from readings/videos _____/10 points
Response to peer's post with specific evidence from post/readings/video _____/10 points
All posts must be time stamped by mid-night on Wednesday!

It seems to me that the whole idea of “manifest destiny” was a justification for expansion, but it can not be denied that it was an ideological justification. The historian David M. Pletcher says that it is difficult to pinpoint the exact portion of idealism or justification involved with manifest destiny, he states, “If you asked a person to define Manifest Destiny, he might tell you it is an ideal, or he might say, "Well, we want the land and this is the easiest way to justify our taking it." It seems to me that the two sides of manifest destiny are intrinsically linked although the ideas seem contrary to each other. The basic idea of manifest destiny is that the United States has the god given destiny to settle of the continent and spread democracy and rights. At the same time this endeavor involved violating the rights of others to property and the right to rule themselves The idea of manifest destiny is, in a sense, an example of cognitive dissonance, the holding of two contrary beliefs at the same time. Anglo-American expansion was inevitable and desired by much of the population. People had to justify the fact that expansion meant taking other groups lands. One way this seemed to be justified was blatant racism, saying those Indians and Mexicans were inferior, the other was the paternal idea of “spreading rights.This second idea is outlined in Walt Whitman’s Editorial, Brooklyn Daily Eagle, July 7, 1846:
ReplyDelete"We love to indulge in thoughts of the future extent and power of this Republic - because with its increase is the increase of human happiness and liberty. . . . What has miserable, inefficient Mexico - with her superstition, her burlesque upon freedom, her actual tyranny by the few over the many - what has she to do with the great mission of peopling the New World with a noble race? Be it ours, to achieve that mission!"
Whitman is speaking of the conquest of Mexico as a noble mission and he voices the idea of many Americans at the time. He says the Mexican government is tyrannical and it is morally justifiable for America to extend it’s republican virtues.
It is interesting how the view of the Mexican American war in the United States has evolved, positive interpretations of the motivation for the war seemed common at first with the persistent belief in manifest destiny and the patriotism generated by the victory of the war. The modern idea is stated clearly with David Pletcher in American Historian, 1998 when he writes,
"This war was an aggressive war in which we attacked a neighbor and however much we won from the war, we do not like to look at the way in which we won it." Still, it is not accurate to say something as black and white as, America used to think the Mexican American war was positive now we think it was negative. Many people alive during the war were vehemently against it, people like Henry David Thoreau, and a good portion of the Whig party, were clearly against the war. It is easy to get trapped in the notion that people today are “free thinkers” and in the past we were not.
Sam, I also find this contradiction quite interesting. The moral justification for taking control of land that isn't in your belonging is that the opposing force is inherently evil and that we must (because of our virtues) take control, that it is our duty to liberate. Whitman states "We are justified in the face of the world, in having treated Mexico with more forbearance than we have ever yet treated an enemy... We have sought peace through every avenue." This ridiculous form of justification demonstrates the true greediness of the doctrine, and the irony behind these actions taken.
DeleteSam, first of all props to you for being the first one to write a response. Second, I read your response and I liked your point that it would be inaccurate to say that our interpretation of the U.S. Invasion went from good to bad because it simply isn't that black and white. And although I agree with you, I must say that there are very few shades of gray in between. I think you would find that the interpretation is far more black and white than we may think, at least among well informed people in today's society. Simply skim through our classmates responses and it is clear that most well informed people would agree that this was an unjust war, and the articles make it clear that "Manifest Destiny" was at its acme of popularity at the time. So I would agree that this interpretation is not black and white but it is pretty close.
DeleteI was particularly interested by reading Jesús Velasco-Márquez’s interpretations of the war. I particularly liked how he outlined the motivations the Mexican government had and the forces at play within that country in the events leading up to the war and that the traditional idea that mexico forced the United States into war was not legitimate. It seems that when looking at this war it is easy to be confused by Mexico's actions but, when viewed in context, they are not irrational. Mexicans saw America as an aggressor, therefore, any admission of land would appear weak and could set the stage for further United States expansion into Mexico. Velasco-Márquez describes the opinion of the press and the political atmosphere when he writes, “The opinion of Mexican journalists and politicians regarding annexation was that Mexico had no other choice but "to impede the United States from appropriating Texas using all means necessary." The objective was to make it clear that whatever desire the United States might have to expand its territory at Mexico's cost would not be accepted passively.” m exaco seems to have adopted a strict policy of aggressive defence out of the not completely unfounded belief that America had designs on even more Mexican territory. Velasco-Márquez also points out that
ReplyDelete“The fragile state of authority was therefore an obstacle to any attempt at negotiated solutions.” The combination of Mexico's distrust of the United States and their unstable political atmosphere mad negotiations impossible. The United States, in turn, was taking advantage of Mexico's instability in order to expand the borders of the US.
There is one aspect of Velasco-Márquez’s argument that i disagree with. It seems to me that, although much of the Mexican American war can be attributed to American expansionism, part of me sympathizes with the taking of Texas and I see both parties as being at fault on this issue. Although the United states Government probably wanted Texas for expansionist reasons that I do not agree with, I also do not agree with Mexico's holding on to Texas after their rebellion. General Santa Anna was clearly and autocrat and he had been trying to reduce the region of Texas's regional autonomy through strict measures. For this reason Texas rebelled and succeeded in that rebellion. Jesús Velasco-Márquez states, “...Mexico asserted from 1836 to 1845, perhaps a bit inflexibly that the secession of Texas was illegitimate, and it reaffirmed its right to incorporate this part of its territory by any means necessary, including the use of force.” For me this is not admonish Mexico from their part, it is true they do not view the succession as legitimate but, for all intents and purposes, Texas had succeeded.
Sam,
DeleteI think it is really important to point out, as you did, the context of Mexico's seemingly irrational decisions. What other choice did they have?? I think that the article you mention here did a really good job giving us the other perspective into the issue. Mexico has no other choice, the US was in clear violation of their national sovereignty-- what nation wouldn't defend themselves in such circumstances?? We pushed and prodded so as to further our own selfish and unjust goals and for that the war should be remembered as one of tyrannical purpose, not one of furthering "America's divine destiny" of equality and liberty.
I think it is interesting to view the comparison of the two countries at the time. It was clear that the United States was far superior, in regards to just about everything. They had a stronger government as well as a more powerful military, there was no way Mexico would be able to fight back against them in any means of battle. The country truly had no other choices because they were not terribly stable as it is.
Delete"The political limitations characterizing the Mexican governments' negotiating capacity were even acknowledged by U.S. representatives". It was quite easy to see for everyone that Mexico was in no place to negotiate. with another country at the time.
DeleteI personally reject the position towards the Mexican war the majority of contemporary figures held during this time period. The spirit of Manifest Destiny was simply a justification to recklessly expand, insensitive to other people who rightfully deserved to live under their respective, independent rule. The superficially innocent American dream to expand was simply a cover for the atrocities committed by people who embodied this. Walt Whitman argued that the U.S. deserves to take control of Mexico. " "What has miserable, inefficient Mexico—with her superstition, her burlesque upon freedom, her actual tyranny by the few over the many—what has she to do with the great mission of peopling the new world with a noble race? Be it ours, to achieve that mission!" Making Mexico the inferior to the United States is another manner of justification, hiding the desire to eliminate any European presence and to exert strength and dominance over land that means nothing to us. Mexico's constitution, although democratically weak, focused on keeping Mexico in the hands of the Mexicans in protection from foreigners. The United States under Polk violated this; the invasion of Mexico was truly an immoral decision. Although Polk did initially want to negotiate, and did not envision a full blown war, that's exactly what he accomplished. Polk is rightfully compared to president Andrew Jackson, notorious for his policy surrounding Native Americans (Trail of Tears). But Polk’s stubborn, aggressive, self-confident personality was the underlying reason for his policy of taking a strong stand and bluffing his opponents — "stonewalling," as we might call if now. The characteristics he shared with his mentor and patron Andrew Jackson." Polk and Whitman are incorrect and their moral basis is lacking. Grant, although he participated in the war, looked back on the conflict with regret. Thoreau adamantly refuted this, stating that the Mexican War was "the work of comparatively a few individuals using the standing government as their tool." These arguments and ideals would ultimately evolve into the culmination of the civil war and social reform, for newly acquired territory would prompt the question: slave state?
ReplyDeleteReflecting back, David Platcher summarizes the evolution of our interpretation of this invasion. He states, During and after the fighting, many Americans accepted this interpretation of the war; few would do so now. If asked about the morality of the war, probably most would profess ignorance or otherwise avoid answering. If presented with the evidence, they would reluctantly admit that their side had had a weak case for fighting. Put more baldly, however, this was a war of aggression." A modern perspective of this conflict would be of censure and disapproval, for the Manifest Destiny facade does not exonerate the immorality of the war.
I agree that the major motivation of America and james K. Polk to start a war with Mexico was for expansionist reasons. Many probably believed the rhetoric about “spreading democracy” but the underlying motivation was economic and power based. I also agree for the most part with your statement that “...the invasion of Mexico was truly an immoral decision.” It is also easy to judge Mexico as being too stubborn but that ignores the fact that may in Mexico acted the way they did out of the justified fear that America had designs on their territory. Jesús Velasco-Márquez states “From Mexico's point of view, the annexation of Texas to the United States was inadmissible for both legal and security reasons.” They did not want to hold on to Mexico just because they were “stubborn”, they wanted to hold on to it so the president of American expansion would not be set. Still, even with this understanding, I think Mexico's decision to hold on to Texas even after they had lost the territory though a rebellion and most others recognized Texas as independent. The people of Texas were responding to the autocratic Santa Ana, their rebellion was not unjustified and they had decided to join the United States. This does not mean I think the Us should have gone to war over this, if they had waited Texas would become so connected to the US that Mexico would not have any rational claim to the territory.
DeleteI agree with you Matt. I think that the war was a gross violation of the liberties and freedoms of the Mexican nation and was incredibly unjustifiable in matters of political and social morals and righteousness. Manifest Destiny is dangerous in its blinding veneration of nationalism taken to the extreme. There is no way to actually justify the aggressive expansion that the US pursued other than that we weren't going to have it any other way. We violated international law by going against the convention of 1828 to violate the sovereignty of Mexico and were the ones who caused the war to happen in the first place. Not only were we ideologically flawed in our mission, we were also blind to the violations of liberties that we wrought on the Mexican people-- something that can never be justified in the human realm and something altogether very anti-American on our part.
DeleteI agree with you Matt that "Manifest Destiny" may have begun as a positive American ideal but became a cover up for the abuse of power that the United States committed. It was wrong the the United States to take advantage of Mexico when it was so vulnerable in its weakened state of government. There are not a lot of arguments in support of Polk and Whitman except for "Manifest Destiny" which was most likely used because it has such a wide sweep of the nation.
DeleteFor me, the arguments of people like Thoreau and Grant most accurately capture the essence of the nature of the Mexican-American War. The fundamental and immediate causes of the war ultimately trace back to our greed and our obsession with the principle of Manifest Destiny. We sought to pursue our destiny and our mission to become one of the world’s great countries and in doing so, we sacrificed the legitimacy of the very principles that our nation was built upon.
ReplyDeletePeople like Polk and Whitman’s justification for the war falls short of truly validating the cause of the war in my opinion and is incredibly contradictory to the beliefs of fundamental Americanism. Whitman once said, “We love to indulge in thoughts of the future extent and power of this Republic - because with its increase is the increase of human happiness and liberty.” I find this expression of sentiment to be particularly unsettling as Whitman is blinded by (as many were) the obsession with the spread of American control over continental America, which was justified, in the public’s eye, by the principles of Manifest Destiny. For me, Manifest Destiny is an incredibly imperialistic ideology and its widespread influence in American culture at the time detracted from its truly tyrannical and twisted nature, which has thus twisted countless interpretations of what the Mexican War was about over the years.
The United States clearly violated the sovereignty of Mexico from the get-go of this whole conflict. Period. The article by Velasco-Marquez clearly demonstrates how the US violated the convention of 1828, which guaranteed that the US would recognize the established Northern borders of Mexico. Yet, look what we did. We annexed Texas, even though Mexico still had a claim of governance over the territory and then we violated Mexico’s sovereignty, as Tindall and Shi put it, by moving an army to the territory north of the Rio Grande, which was contested territory and considered an act of war by the Mexicans. We did all the pushing and shoving to get the gears of war turning. The Mexicans have a right and should defend themselves if a country were to violate their sovereignty in the way that we did. We are the violators, the aggressors and the perpetrators—we violated international law, disregarded the sovereignty of the Mexican nation and pursued unjust means (contrary to our founding principles) to win the expansive New Mexico, California and Texas territories at all costs.
Chris, I couldn’t have put it any better. My views are exactly the same as yours: the U.S. unquestioningly broke international law by completely disregarding the sovereignty of the Mexican nation. As Pletcher states, much of the world (namely, Europe) saw the United states as blatant hypocrites in consideration of Manifest Destiny. Foreigners held “a combination of lack of respect and a conviction that Americans were essentially hypocrites to talk about ideals then aim at expanding their land holdings.” He goes on to assert, “The Americans did a great deal of talking and writing about liberty, but at the same time, they expanded the idea of Manifest Destiny. It was their destiny to expand across North America.” This makes me question: who actually GAVE America the right to conquer the whole continent? Who actually proclaimed that Americans were a superior, noble, nation? The answer is: nobody. Americans were greedy, and looked to Manifest Destiny as a (rather unmoral) justification. I’m not trying to be cynical, but let’s be real: the underlying motivations for the majority of humans are selfish.
DeleteWith this in mind, Mexico clearly had the right and duty to defend itself. The U.S. made the first step of aggression by stationing troops in the disputed land along the Rio Grande. Mexico, without wrong, saw this as encroachment on territory it considered theirs, and thus attacked the U.S. forces in defense. It’s clear from Velasco-Márquez’s article that the motivation of Mexico throughout the conflict was defense, not provocation.
People like Thoreau and the abolitionists of the time saw through the cunning of Polk and the Southern aggressors. The Missouri Compromise guaranteed that Texas’ admittance into the Union would make it a slave state, something of great concern to many and in and of itself highly contrary to the American ideals of liberty and justice for all. Thoreau and others saw this and as the video describes, they were very outspoken against the war as a result. Hmm…I am seeing a lot of hypocrisy in the underlying purposes of promoting the war thus far. So much for the promotion of American liberty and equality, more like the promotion of imperialistic, expansionist-pigheadedness by fools like President Polk. America fell short of its principles and I think that as time goes on people have realized more and more that the Mexican War may not have been as grand as it was made out to seem in the grand scheme of the American narrative.
ReplyDeleteAs evidenced in the video by Grant’s confession in the second video, the truth of the war was one of tyranny, imperialism and a violation of American principles. Grant talked about how unjust the war was and how it was something along the lines of being “one of the worst examples of a powerful country violating the rights and liberties of a weaker country in history.” That really says it all. As time has gone on, I think the true nature of the war has come out—Tindall and Shi point out how it was an incredibly deadly war, Grant (someone who was involved firsthand in the war) confessed it was unjust and contrary to American principles and other evidence in Tindall and Shi points out that it only helped further American sectionalism and send the country down the road to civil war. So even despite its inherent benefit for the American people, the war solidified the prospects of a certain civil war and hurt us in that way too. Everywhere there is evidence that the true nature of the Mexican-American War was one of unjust and rather anti-American purpose and I think it is naïve to think that the war ever did more to help us than harm us.
After reading only Chapter 13 in Tindall and Shi, I was already heavily leaning toward the conviction that the U.S. was largely (if not absolutely) at fault in context of the Mexican-American War. Now, after reading the interview with historian David Pletcher and the article by Mexican historian Jesús Velasco-Márquez, that conviction of mine has only grown stronger. Firstly, there is the problem of the merits of America’s “Manifest Destiny” during the 19th century. As Pletcher points out, it may have been a truly sincere ideal in some Americans’ minds: that the American people have a divine right and duty to spread their exemplary democracy across the whole continent, in order to promote the prosperity of humanity in general. That sure sounds really nice and noble, but reality was far from it. Much of “Manifest Destiny” was simply, as Pletcher puts it, “a justification, in that [Americans] wanted territory and needed an excuse or justification for a push into territory that they did not control.” He continues, “It's a kind of early projection of Anglo-saxon supremacy and there's a racist element to it.” This is consistent to what Tindall and Shi mention in Chapter 13: that Manifest Destiny was largely a justification for American greediness and aggression to obtain more land. In my eyes, American expansion was not very morally sound, considering how many Native Americans we displaced and our aggression toward Mexico.
ReplyDeleteFurthermore, Velasco-Márquez asserts convincingly that Mexico never took on an aggressive stance toward the U.S., at least until the U.S. encroached on controversial land. In dealing with Texas, Velasco-Márquez shows that Mexico was non-aggressive even after the U.S. decided to annex Texas (which Mexico not unjustifiably still considered its own):
"Mexico's anti-belligerent posture in favor of negotiations was confirmed October 15, 1845, when its foreign relations minister, Manuel de la Peña y Peña, notified U.S. consul John Black
'...that although the Mexican nation was gravely offended by the United States due to its actions in Texas — belonging to Mexico — the government was willing to receive a commissioner who would arrive in this capital from the United States possessing full faculties to settle the current dispute in a peaceful, reasonable and respectable way.' "
Clearly, the U.S. was the aggressor. Both videos for this assignment further support my conclusion, as it quotes Ulysses S. Grant commenting on how the Mexican-American war was “one of the most unjust ever waged by a stronger against a weaker nation.” Polk’s justifications for the war were faulty at best; it was obvious that he wanted to use force to coerce Mexico in relinquishing the disputed lands, and wrongly twisted reality to depict Mexico as the aggressors. I can’t help agreeing with Thoreau and Grant, while shaking my head at Whitman and Polk.
Justin, I do not necessarily agree with your point that the U.S. was the complete and total aggressor in the Mexican-American War. I do see America as the main aggregator, but in some places I find that Mexico was at fault.
DeleteTo me it seemed that one often overlooked aspect in these readings, aside from Tindall and Shi, which explains this somewhat, is that Mexico welcomed the settlers into Texas, assuming they pledged certain loyalties to the Catholic Church and the Mexican Government. When they did this they were taking on certain risks. By welcoming the Americans into Texas, they were somewhat opening themselves up to the risk of eventual annexation by the American Settlers who were living there.
Furthermore, having previously been a colony of Spain, I think it would be understandable to assume that they would be somewhat lenient to the idea of independent rule, or separation as Texas wanted from Mexico. Mexico continued to hold onto the land and dispute the borders, even if it did not have much value or was somewhat hypocritical of them.
In my view, some of the choices made by Mexico, mixed with their unstable and somewhat sporadic government, make them somewhat responsible; which is why I feel blaming the U.S. entirely is not a fair accusation.
I totally agree with your points Justin. I don't see any viable and just justification for going to war with Mexico from a US standpoint. It was merely a war fought out of selfish interests, not one of furthering ideals of liberty and equality. I don't see how, especially since so much time has passed and the adrenaline of the moment has long passed, anyone could possibly justify this war. We violated international law, abused our military might to dominate and take advantage of Mexico's instability and clearly violated the sovereignty of the Mexican nation. I, too, shake my head at Polk and Whitman-- those selfish tyrants.
ReplyDeleteI think that the idea of Manifest Destiny can help to explain the US’s motives for waging war on Mexico, but (unlike many Americans at the time) I do not think it justifies them under any circumstances. I think that Americans in favor of war with Mexico were blinded by their ideologies and overwhelming thirst for expansion. As Whitman puts it, Americans believed that their country was justifiably superior and “…its increase is the increase of human happiness and liberty.” It was the genuine belief that American expansion was a noble cause, and that the country’s destiny favored it.
ReplyDeleteHistorian Robert Johannsen argues that “romantic notions” sweeping the country at the time also swayed Americans. It’s easy for us to say now how skewed and hypocritical people were at the time, but we must remember the (highly influential) atmosphere of the age. America was truly undergoing a renaissance of flowing industry, science, arts, and intellectual achievement. The idea that life had no limits and that the country could achieve anything was a dominant idea at the time. Today, we don’t look on the idea of Manifest Destiny with surges of romantic optimism, but in the nineteenth century many people would have. It seemed as though the world was at America’s fingertips, and going to war was an insignificant obstacle in taking it.
I think that those who supported the war supported it because they felt like it was America’s right, and completely ignored the equally rightful claims of Mexico. Mexico had as much if not tremendously more claim to the territory and had no means of protecting it against the powerful US forces. The only thing standing between the US and Mexico was a border treaty asserting Mexico’s claim over the area. When the US annexed Texas, the act was, according to Marquez, “violation of the fundamental principles of international law.” Where the US had the choice to go to war, Mexico had none.
The same ideologies that preached equality and just treatment of all beings, also preached the unlimited power of man. While some Americans acknowledged the rights of the Mexicans, others favored the romantic ideals in unlimited expansion. Both sides are understandable, but not necessarily justifiable.
I agree with you Katie that those who supported the Mexican War completely ignored Mexico's right to their land. There were two treaties brought up, one from 1828 and the other from 1836 claiming that Mexico had the legal rights to those lands. Americans were so consumed with their idea of "Manifest Destiny" that they were blinded by the pressure to expand and make the United States a world power. Mexico was unable to defend itself, although it fought quite a good battle. Mexico had a weak government, was unstable, and did not have complete control over its lands. The United States chose to go to war as you say and the Mexicans had no choice which I completely agree with.
DeleteI completely agree with the fact that Manifest Destiny is understandable yet not justifiable as it was just something to cover America's thirst for land. I also think that the romantic notions blowing across the country were important yet i feel as though trying to use them to justify our expansion is wrong in a sense. Yes at the time it would have been a major force that we can't completely comprehend. Yet that doesn't change the fact that what we did was wrong and that blaming it on romantic notions is still just us trying to escape from what we did much like blaming the war on Manifest Destiny. Also as understandable as the idea of us being invincible is i feel as though we should not have felt such at the time. Even though we were flourishing the people who got the invincible feeling were those who migrated west yet so many of them died i can't seem to comprehend how they could think themselves invincible instead of just smart or lucky because i mean look at the Donner party incident, they clearly were in control of the world.
DeleteKatie, excellent post. I really liked how you brought up the context of the times. Looking at this scenario from a 21st century perspective can really alter our opinions, so I liked how you incorporated the relevant 19th century romanticism into your argument. Robert Johannsen, the same historian whom you quoted, also remarks, "This is all part of this idea of boundlessness of no limits. This was a romantic notion that through an act of will, Americans could achieve this greatness for themselves and for their nation." This argument ties back to our study of "transcendentalism" in English class. The transcendental themes of self-reliance, accepting what God has planned for you and having confidence in your self-worth all directly relate to Manifest Destiny. Americans that expansion was a part of God's plan and that they must confidently take the initiative to achieve it. You've got love how these two classes are aligning right now!
DeleteI agree that the United States was not just in their actions in the Mexican-American war. Although most people supported Polk’s decision at the time it was out of greed and self interest. They justified it it by using this idea of the “Manifest Destiny” that claimed it was god’s given right that they have the land. At the time I think many people knew it was wrong but went along with it. There were however, people like Ulysses Grant and Henry Thoreau who publicly stated that the US was at fault. Grant participated in the Mexican war and later admitted that it was unjust and wrong to have taken advantage on a weaker country.
ReplyDeletePolk declared that the US was justified for fighting the war because the Mexican were the ones who acted first. This however, is not true. Polk sent troops down to Rio Grande and provoked the war so that Polk could take the moral ground and fight for Texas. I think provoking a fight is just as bad as starting one. Lincoln who was a congress man of Illinois at the time, asked Polk to name the spot where American blood had been spilled so as to know for sure that it didn’t occur on Mexican grounds.
The United States believed that they were the ideal republic and should set an example for other countries. By force annexation of Texas, the United States went against their national values. Pletcher says that other countries lost respect for the US after the war because although they wrote about rights and liberty they went against their beliefs when they took Texas from the Mexicans.
I thought it unwise for Polk to want to annex new territory considering the abolition movement at the time. With the creation of the Liberty party in 1840 and the escalation of pamphlets and protests it seemed like the wrong time to adopt a new state that would then be determined either a slave state or non-slave state. Tindall and Shi said, “ By 1830 the coastal region of eastern Texas had approximately 20,000 white settlers and 1,000 black slaves brought in to work the cotton. the newcomers quickly outnumbered the 5,000 mexicans...”. Considering how many slaves were in Texas by 1830 it would be likely that Texas would become a slave state. This would further upset abolitionists and put more tension and separation between the Northern region of the country. Polk should have been looking out for his country as a whole.
As a side note, I think it is interesting that Jackson was presented with the decision to recognize Texas but didn't until his last day in office. Also, Van Buren ignored the issue his entire presidency. Both thought it would lead to a civil war. However, when Polk becomes president it becomes one of his goals to take Texas.
I very much agree with the points that you make. Polk was wrong in saying that it was mexico who first provoked it when Ulysses S. Grant, who was sent to fight, said, "We were sent to provoke a fight, but it was essential that Mexico commence it." It seems Polk was just trying to justify his actions to the rest of the world by saying that Mexico made the first move. Polk sent troops with the intention of starting a war.
DeleteI also agree with you, Marissa. Tindall and Shi explain that “Manifest Destiny” at its worst was “a cluster of flimsy rationalizations for naked greed and imperial ambitions” (434). Pletcher similarly explains how Americans had two different sides: fighters for liberty, but also greedy expansionists. Before reading these texts and seeing the videos I did not understand the contradictions between the actions of many Americans. It is interesting that most people at the time supported Polk’s decision as you mentioned. I think this was because he did a good job of gaining public opinion for expansion and for the war itself. Overall, I really enjoyed your post and thought your side note at the end was something interesting to consider.
DeleteYou say that "At the time...many people knew it was wrong but went along with it" but I don't believe so. I agree with the bulk of your argument, that the U.S. had no justification to its actions in the Mexican War and any of its intentions under the idea of manifest destiny, but I believe that the reason the Mexican War occurred was because the United States was acting egotistically - that the majority of Americans were acting egotistically. The words of Historian David Pletcher well reflect the words of the radicals of the time: "This war was an aggressive war in which we attacked a neighbor and however much we won from the war, we do not like to look at the way in which we won it." However, these radicals, like Walt Whitman, Henry David Thoreau and Ulysses S. Grant were just that - radicals. Not necessarily radicals in their actions but radicals in the way they thought. These men were representative of the minority - the people of the United States that were already beginning to realize what limitations should exist upon the power of the United States government. There were also those who represented the Jeffersonian Ideal that a successful government cannot govern an area effectively if it is too big. And there were the abolitionists who worried that expansion westward would result in the expansion of slave-friendly states. I think that Pletcher would agree: it was because these parties were not yet widespread and popular enough that they were overtaken by the massive party that believed in the idea of manifest destiny and therefore partly why the Mexican War occurred.
DeleteThough the United States was in some respect the aggressor in the situation, the United States motives were not all bad during the Mexican-American War. I would not agree with the claim The United States was absolutely at fault. I would however, agree with the idea that the American philosophy of “Manifest Destiny” was deeply flawed. Pletcher seems to argue this point in my mind quite successfully. The idea that America has the divine right to rule “from sea to shining sea” is a flawed and potentially dangerous notion. Obviously this was just an excuse for America to spread their power further, by claiming we had the divine right of God.
ReplyDeleteHaving said that, I feel that to an extent I agree with Walt Whitman. He seems to lay out a rather extreme argument, but in the end, the people of Texas desired to be free and Mexico should have recognized that yearning as they themselves worked for independence from Spain. It was almost as if it were an understood principle that Mexico would understand the call for independence from the people of Texas.
I do not think the war was all positive, or at all completely justified, but the war was at least somewhat worthwhile with some positive effects I see. Thoreau opposes the war because he feels that it could be used as a means of expanding slavery. I do see this as a good point, though as part of an agreement reached, California is admitted to the Union as a free state. The idea that the war escalated tensions between pro-slave Southerners and abolitionists in the North has some ground to it, but in my view the Civil War was essentially inevitable. The South was never going to simply give up the institution of slavery without a fight. The Mexican-American War may have expedited the timing of the war, but it certainly did not cause it. The division that was forming within The United States was becoming wider and more distinct despite the Mexican-American War. From a modern perspective, I find it unfair to make this war a main cause of the Civil War.
On the contrary, a view against this war, which makes the most sense to me, is the idea that Jesús Velasco-Márquez seemed to touch on. In a way, it was a questionable idea that the United States was almost annexing sovereign territory from Mexico against international law, but they did somewhat makes this happen on their own. Mexico welcomed the Americans to the territory and eventually due to the political instability and inefficiency of Mexico, the people decided to succeed. Had Mexico been more opposed, or even really at all opposed, to the Americans moving into the territory of Mexico I would have more issue with the annex of the land. Given that Mexico essentially welcomed the Americans into the country and the area of Texas, they somewhat set themselves up. I do understand that given this Mexico may be upset and a perspective of Jesús Velasco-Márquez might call this the “American Invasion”. Aside from the welcoming nature of Mexico at the beginning, I do understand this principle.
The Mexican-American War, unjust or not, was still not solely the fault of America. Mexico’s allowance of American’s in Texas set the stage for a rebellion, and Mexico’s own past history with Spain seemed to set a precedent (false) of understanding. Whether we agree with the rational or not, the interpretations from a modern perspective may be different than the time period.
Your argument makes a lot of sense, Chase, and I agree that the war is too complicated to put all of the blame onto one party. I do think that the US was the principal aggressor, however. I think it would have been a completely different story had the US merely assisted Texas in asserting its independence, but that was not the case. I agree with your point that the American belief in Manifest Destiny was the greatest fault. It was in annexing Texas that the US took advantage of its power over a weaker army and justified it with the ideas in Manifest Destiny. This motive very much displays the inflated ego and ambition of Americans at the time.
DeleteI agree that the war was worthwhile in that Polk achieved his goal of obtaining California and Texas, but the means he used were in direct defiance of international law and the Monroe Doctrine (which, though not official foreign policy, does pick up a lot of steam and slows down some attempts at American Imperialism). And even then, the annexation of Texas is unjustifiable because Texas didn't really want to be annexed. It's government did, but the people were less enthused. And if *that's* not enough unjustifiability for you (no, "unjustifiability" is not a word, but I'm too lazy to come up with something more boringly conventional), the method in which Polk annexed Texas was unconstitutional. It was a greedy move motivated primarily by political gain.
DeleteMy first impression of the Mexican War came from Thoreau after recently reading Walden. He was strongly against the war and took such a strong stance that he even went to jail for refusing to pay his poll tax. From this I was wary of what exactly occurred during the war for such a renowned figure to so adamantly oppose it and this feeling war correct. After reading Chapter 13 and both excerpts provided, I absolutely agree with Thoreau in that the war was unnecessary and unjust.
ReplyDeleteBefore the Mexican War even took place, the idea of “Manifest Destiny” had delved into the minds of most Americans. It was stated repeatedly through all of the material that the definition of such depended on the person but the main description was that it was “a conviction that God intended North America to be under the control of Americans. It's a kind of early projection of Anglo-saxon supremacy and there's a racist element to it” (Pletcher). This sense of entitlement that rippled through the nation continued into the beginnings of the Mexican War.
Chapter 13, although Tindall and Shi may try their hardest, was quite biased against the Mexican war, helping me form my bias as well. I do not believe the United States had any legal justification to take land away from Mexico that was legally theirs. Polk claimed that “Mexico had crossed over the U.S. border, had invaded our territory and had cawed the shedding of U.S. blood in U.S. territory” while Mexico was only trying to defend what was rightfully theirs claimed in a treaty made in 1828. The Congressional decree issued on July 6, 1846 states that Mexico was not declaring war on the United States but rather was declaring their need to defend themselves and the “country’s territorial integrity.” Velasco-Marquez stated that the war “was not a result of arrogance, nor of irresponsibility, but rather the only possible response to the arguments and the actions of the U.S. government.” This is a biased point of view but I stand by it and agree. I believe that the United States unjustly waged war with Mexico because of their belief in “Manifest Destiny” and their fear of Britain and other foreign countries invading the land.
Many of the arguments presented are different than those posed by the opposition at the time of the war. Most Americans agreed with expansion but abolitionists in the North saw it as a chance for the South to gain more pro-slavery land which was a fearful idea. Also the “Northeast and East Coast felt they would loose power if the United States admitted more states in to the Union” (Pletcher). These ideas have evolved into issues more relevant to today and they have become slightly more sophisticated. Whether or not the arguments are different, the opposition to the Mexican war began in the 19th century and has held strong to the present day.
Although I do not agree with the war I will say that it had valuable outcomes. The country gained an incredible amount of land and political leaders gained valuable military skills.
Colby, I completed agree. I think that while historical context and the perspective of the time is an important aspect to consider when attempting to form convictions, today's viewpoint can teach us a lot about the true meaning of the War. However, I must disagree with you when it comes to the outcome of the War. I don't believe that the War resulted in any real, lasting, valuable outcomes. In fact, I believe that the Mexican-American War directly caused the Civil War, due to the factions that emerged with the fighting. I too have been reading Walden, and I find your point about Thoreau intriguing. I think that it would be interesting to look at the War through the lens of transcendentalism to truly evaluate the fundamental religious/Godly issues of a War that stemmed from a supposed grant from God himself (Manifest Destiny).
DeleteWell i'm just going to come straight out and say that America is completely at fault for this disgrace of a war. We had no real right to take the actions we did and what is even worse than that is our trying to justify it through "Manifest Destiny". We came up with this theory that god intended us to rule from sea to sea in North America, simply to make ourselves not look like greedy expansionists. Manifest Destiny is a hoax and really it should not even be considered as a viable reason for our expansion. Ideas that are viable are that we want land, that we should control Texas and California because they are in our way and the people there are not exactly loyal to Mexico. I am just not a fan of the Mexican-American war and think that Ulysses S. Grant was very much so justified in saying that the war was, “one of the most unjust ever waged by a stronger against a weaker nation”.
ReplyDeleteI would also like to point out that i do not agree with Jesús Velasco-Márquez because the way he paints the war, it seems as though America should be water boarded for our actions which i do not agree with either. He states that the name of the war in Mexico is "The U.S. Invasion". That's really odd as it seems that America is very good at starting controversial wars, like the American War of Independence or the War of Northern Aggression. I find it really quite comical that in all three cases both sides just can't come to an agreement on the name. That is slightly beside the point but Márquez really does make the war seem like it was all America's fault, which i do agree with. I don't agree with him going and saying that we should have tried a more diplomatic solution as our actions do make sense. I mean what is the easiest way to acquire wanted territory, well war. Also any diplomatic solution would also cost us large sums of money and who really wants to lose that much money over a desert.
On one hand though i do like what the war did for the country. It allowed us to expand all the way across the country and gave us access to many valuable minerals and ports. Yet even though these are the positive good there were some negatives that should be factored in. The main one being that slavery was now going to be expanded in the United States. This is due to New Mexico and Texas being below the Mason Dixon line. Also Texas already had approximately 1000 slaves according to Tindal and Shi. This meant that Texas would become a slave state and almost push the scales towards slavery as they now had another state that would back the south in it's support of slavery. This also led towards the most costly war in American history. As the divide created here was what gave the south enough power to believe they could succeed. Some people may think i'm crazy but since when has a war been started by a weaker force. Normally it is the stronger force that starts the war and the weaker force is on the defense until it either becomes strong enough to over power the attackers or it falls. Being that the South succeeded i believe they had to feel like they could win meaning they some how were able to gain an edge in there mind over the north and i feel as though that edge was Texas and New Mexico as now they had two more states support which either counter balanced the debate or made it so they had more voice than the north did in the slave debate.
The Mexican American war was one of the most unjust wars in history. Yet i agree with it needing to happen as America was going to get control over that land one way or another due to the crazy idea of Manifest Destiny.
Yes I do agree that it was a war that didn't need to really happen. after Texas had declared independence from Mexico although settlers prior agreed to support and show loyalty to the country of mexico in order to settle on their land it was clear from their draft of their constitution should mexico be unable to be the uniformed government necessary for their basic needs then they would withdraw. At this point mexico was unstable and of course broke away from mexico successfully. However The U.s. involvement into the matter I believe was legal up to the point of accepting Texas and protecting it. To excel the war where they loose territory in both California and New Mexico and continue to the capital and beat the heck out of a nation just seemed completely belligerent to me.
DeleteThat desert might be worth more than you think. However I do agree with you that the middle of the road approach is the way to look at the U.S. actions. I think that you are correct in saying that it is the Americans fault for starting the war. It is clear as crystal that we provoked them. The problem is that, as pointed out in your response, people take the modern perspective too much and believe that there was a way to avoid war that would be easy to make. The war was the most effective way, and In my opinion at least the war was a product of the time and the reason peace was not viewed as an option was that to the people of the U.S. it was not a viable option. People will always be able to look back in time and criticize the decisions that the people made, but it is learning from the poor decisions that matters most.
DeleteI believe that the historian David M. Pletcher was correct when he said manifest destiny was just an excuse for Americans to expand west. I agree with with him when he states that they are hypocrites. It is not Americans divine right to rule over the country and the people in it. Pletcher stated, "The Americans did a great deal of talking and writing about liberty, but at the same time, they expanded the idea of Manifest Destiny." It's no one's God given right to rule over anybody else.
ReplyDeleteHaving said that the Mexican American War did have a few positive outcomes such as Texas splitting from Mexico, which is what they wanted to do when they declared independence.I do agree with the points that Jesús Velasco-Márquez makes, when he states that it was one of the only response from Mexico. Mexico was forced to defend themselves because the United States was forcefully taking their land. Although I do think it is a bit extreme to state, "the armed conflict between Mexico and the United States from 1846 to 1848 was the product of deliberate aggression and should therefore be referred to as "The U.S. War Against Mexico." The United States is not all to blame for this war starting. Ulysses S. Grant said when he was a young officer serving in the war, "We were sent to provoke a fight, but it was essential that Mexico commence it". Both of the parties are to blame because both failed at peaceful negotiations.
The Mexican-American War was caused by mistakes made by Mexico and the United States.
I would agree with historian Jesus Velasco-Marquez and his arguments about the variation of interpretations of the U.S. Invasion. I was honestly shocked when President Polk stated that the United States was left with no other choice but to invade Mexico in order to protect its own national security, and that Mexico was ultimately to blame for the U.S. Invasion. This, in my opinion, is a remarkable example of shameful greed in U.S. politics. All I've been able to take away from these articles is that America will take what it wants from less powerful nations and then justify their actions by blaming the other country or by hiding behind fluffy language like, "Manifest Destiny". What a load of bs... If God is a democratic being, which the term "Manifest Destiny" clearly suggests, wouldn't he want us to give the Mexicans a vote on whether or not we invade them? This could also apply to the Native Americans. Since when is a richer nation stealing the land from a poorer nation a part of the Divine Plan of a Democratic God?
ReplyDeleteBut who was really surprised by this whole idiotic concept of "Manifest Destiny"? Historian David M. Pletcher wasn't, he said that this concept was foreshadowed by America's desire for Canada between the Revolution and the War of 1812 and the rationalization of the Louisiana Purchase. You could even go as far to say that "Manifest Destiny" and the U.S. Invasion are events that foreshadow this country's actions today. Today the United States has troops in over 150 countries around the world and the U.S. is constantly involved in a war with some chaotic nation trying to spread democracy because God told us to. That being said, I would not say that the concepts of "Manifest Destiny" have changed very much. The United States continues to try to spread its democratic ways all over the world for one reason and one reason only, we ran out of land to call American, so now we have no choice but to make the rest of the world as similar to America as possible.
I agree with you James. The idea that Jesus Velasco-Marquez brings up about stronger nations taking from weaker nations is also reflected in Grants thoughts on the war. He said that it was clearly an unfair war and that the United States were much stronger than Mexico. I think badly of the American government during this time period because they tried to blame Mexico for starting the war and claiming that it was America's God-given right to obtain all this land. I also found it very interesting that David M. Pletcher thought the idea of Manifest Destiny was foreshadowed in the Louisiana Purchase and America's desire for Canada. But it was even more fascinating to me that European countries did not fear America for their desire for more land; rather they thought it hypocritical of them to overlook liberties for more land. These sources helped me better understand the war and the imperfections of our government's past.
DeleteThe Mexican American War was the deadliest war in American military history and the start of the war did not paint Americans in a positive light. David Pletcher’s statement, “This war was an aggressive war in which we attacked a neighbor and however much we won from the war, we do not like to look at the way in which we won it” demonstrates that Americans cannot be proud of this brutal and costly war. Jesus Velasco-Marquez said that Americans had “an outrageous Machiavellian objective.” The ends justified the means in the Mexican American War. Polk was determined to annex California, Texas, New Mexico, and Oregon no matter the consequences. Marquez clearly thinks that the United States was at fault for the war, as he says that the war should be called “The U.S. War Against Mexico.” He later says, “The U.S. government was not seeking to protect its territorial security, nor did it have other supposed demands, but rather it was determined to take over a territory legitimately belonging to Mexico.” It is embarrassing that the United Sates portrayed this as an equal war, when in fact the U.S. clearly started it and waited for Mexico to fight back. Marquez said, “Their interpretations have been biased, taking some official declarations and newspaper articles out of context and using them as supposed evidence of Mexico's exaggerated belligerency.” Before analyzing this war, I never understood the true start of the war and how many lives were lost throughout it.
ReplyDeleteIt is interesting that European countries did not fear America’s idea of Manifest Destiny, rather there was a “lack of respect and a conviction that Americans were essentially hypocrites to talk about ideals then aim at expanding their land holdings.” In “Looking Back: A Just War?” there was a Romantic notion that made Americans believe they had no limits. Americans wanted to dominate in all aspects, not just with land ownership, but with arts, intellect, and other aspects of life. I think it is great that Americans had goals, but the Manifest Destiny made people too ambitious that they did not see the costly outcomes of their decisions.
I agree with Henry David Thoreau’s encouragement for the American people to follow their conscience during the war. The United States of America is such a great country because of the opportunities and freedoms for citizens. During this time period, Americans did not have those same rights. People feared expansion because they thought the government could only work successfully in a confined region. Also, in “Looking Back: A Just War?” Grant describes the unfairness of the war and that it was clearly a weaker nation against a stronger one. He said that the U.S. was at fault because it did not live up to its ideology, which had always stressed freedom and democracy. I agree with Grant’s statement and think that America lost its purpose during this war. Overall, I think the United States was at fault for the war and I have a more judgmental view of the American government during this time period after analyzing the Mexican American War.
To reiterate the sentiments of many of my classmates, I must say that I too believe that this war was essentially one of American aggression. Completely avoidable, President Polk provoked the Mexican government in a way that promoted diplomatic disunity and disregard for basic international relations. Furthermore, the War resulted in internal issues that would later go on to directly cause the Civil War.
ReplyDeleteHistory shows its first inklings of Manifest Destiny inspired imperialistic actions with the westward expansion movement, which displaced thousands -- if not millions -- of Native American peoples, yet was considered to be just due to the fact that those moving possessed a manifest from God that permitted them to rightfully voyage. Pletcher explains this idea well when he states how "The Americans did a great deal of talking and writing about liberty, but at the same time, they expanded the idea of Manifest Destiny." In fact, this explanation essentially holds true for American actions at the border as well as in the West. We mustn't forget that Americans infringed upon Mexican land. Just because the American population in some regions outnumbered the Mexican by 4:1, Americans did not own the land. In fact, Americans were illegally crossing a border.
Pletcher highlights the sectionalism that began to emerge as a result of the conflict when discussing how "Expansion was always a very divisive issue that provoked as much opposition as support in some parts of the country. At first, the opposition to expansion came from those who believed that the United States could not succeed as an experiment in self-government if it grew too large." One major party that maintained this ideal was the Whig Party, which maintained opposition against the War with Mexico. In fact, as the War waged on, the decisive issues that separated the North and the South, namely slavery, further divided the two, and hastened a climax. In Tindall and Shi, it is argued that the sanctions that the war forced to further emerge is a huge part of the interpretation of the War overall.
Of course, the war has a different interpretation from the opinion of Mexico. Jesús Velasco-Márquez argues that the Mexican people only took up arms because it "was the only option available to defend their rights and territorial integrity." In fact, to them the purpose of the War was never to fight, but to protect. The borders being infringed upon were rightfully theirs, and they needed to protect their land. Ironically, Americans would, centuries later, adopt this own point of view when the roles became reversed. In fact, during the signing of the Treaty of Guadalupe Hidalgo, one American, Nicholas Trist, expressed his true feelings, saying "Could those Mexicans have seen into my heart at that moment, they would have known that my feeling of shame as an American was far stronger than theirs could be as Mexicans." Personally, I believe that this sentiment sums up the spirit of the War, as well as its ultimate interpretation today.
Morgan, I think that’s an interesting point you bring up about the native Americans and how hypocritic the Americans were. They constantly talked about liberty, but took the Native Americans’ land away and then the Mexicans’ land away. Pletcher even talks about how the Europeans viewed the Americans during this time. The Europeans lost respect for them and considered them to be hypocrites. I also agree with you about the part of the border. The Mexicans were simply protecting their border that the Americans were so rudely intruding upon. Now when we look back on this time, we are more embarrassed than proud of what we did to Mexico.
DeleteMorgan, I agree with your point about sectionalism emerging as a result of expansionism. Annexing Texas became especially controversial in terms of slavery. Some people even wondered if the reason for annexing Texas was planned so as to promote slavery. The abolitionist movement was very active at this time in the north and ideas like these put northerners in even more opposition to annexing Texas. The southern states on the other hand who were proslavery were in favor. This helped widen the gap between the regions.
DeleteSo here I am, having just finished with all the evidence before me, broiling my anti-American anger into a firestorm speech that will rock the socks of APUSH forever. But then I scan through the previous opinions and realize that I'm preaching to the converted. Why do history students have to be so intelligent?
ReplyDeleteLook, as much of a shock as this might be, I don't think that America had any justification for provoking a war with Mexico. It was an understandable and probably a very good decision for Polk, considering that he obtained California and Texas, but the rationale behind it smells of more BS than that time I put laxatives in Mr. Brown's cow trough. The phrase "Manifest Destiny" is an ideological nothing: it is, as David M. Pletcher put it, "...in part, an expression of a genuine ideal on the part of Americans. But it was also a justification, in that they wanted territory and needed an excuse or justification for a push into territory that they did not control." Tindall and Shi emphasize over and over Polk's focus on geographical gain, even so much as claiming that "Polk's intrigue had put the ablest Mexican general [Santa Anna] back in command of the enemy army" (460). The war was about land, and little more.
The very annexation of Texas was also unjustifiable. Not only did it break international law, as outlined by Jesus Velasco-Marquez, but it also broke our own unofficial foreign policy: the Monroe Doctrine. Which, I believe, is picking up steam by this point. If European imperialism is so horrid and unfair, then why are we doing the same? Texas is in its full right to declare independence from Santa Anna's regime, but we cannot be allowed to annex it without the consent of the people as a whole. The same would apply to California, had California not been stuffed with Polk's settlers for the expressed purpose of independence and subsequent annexation (Tindall and Shi, 458-459). Of course, perhaps Americans truly did believe in Manifest Destiny, but if the concept is a hypocrisy of preexisting beliefs then it is not so much an ideal as it is a catchy excuse.
As far as Douglass's and Thoreau's issue over slavery goes, I have no definitive argument against Manifest Destiny. This is partly because I'm a flaming racist and partly because that Manifest Destiny was innately "...a kind of early projection of Anglo-saxon supremacy and there's a racist element to it" (Pletcher). It doesn't really matter if Manifest Destiny was an excuse or not; the goal was equally naked.
Which, I suppose, applies to the entire concept. We want land, we take land. Veni vidi vici. Or somesuch. The cause to get what we want is rather trivial. This is especially true in hindsight: a post-Civil War Ulysses S. Grant wrote, "I regard the [Mexican] war as one of the most unjust ever waged by a stronger against a weaker nation." As time goes on, the disillusionment sets in, and people begin to recognize what happened and why. Today, we swear off Manifest Destiny as expansionist propaganda without a second thought.
I don't know how much deeper I can go into this analysis. Manifest Destiny clearly had racist undertones: Whitman wrote, "What has miserable, inefficient Mexico - with her superstition, her burlesque upon freedom, her actual tyranny by the few over the many - what has she to do with the great mission of peopling the New World with a noble race? Be it ours, to achieve that mission!" According to Tindall and Shi, Calhoun sent a letter to the British explaining the merits of slavery and that the annexation of Texas would be a step forward in that industry (453). The dispute whether Manifest Destiny was a God-given truth or a sham of a justification doesn't mean anything. It was corrupt to begin with, and clearly meant to propel political agendas.
As Yahtzee Croshaw once said the the inventor of the feces-powered helicopter, "This crap will not fly!" I echo this sentiment.
Eric I agree with you that the U.S. was not justified in provoking the war, but I think that the idea the U.S. was completely unjustified is a little oversimplified. On the surface it is easy to look at and see that it broke international law, including the 1828 border treaty. It is also easy to see why Mexico would see it is an act of war. Despite all this, I think that it is more than a matter of "Veni vidi vici". Starting in 1823, Mexico welcomed American settlers, and then failed to properly regulate their borders until the number of Americas was 10 times more than the number of Mexicans in Texas in 1835, over 10 years before the war. With the majority of Texans being Americans, it is no wonder that there would be some desire to join America. The U.S. actually did therefore have SOME right to wanting Texas, which is why this goes deeper than America just seeing land and wanting it. Mexico didn't demonstrate much interest in Texas until the U.S. wanted it
DeleteAaron, that's like saying that Spain should annex Mexico because Mexico is populated by mostly Spanish immigrants. The people of Texas declared independence on their own accord; they had no wishes to join the United States, or at least not in the foreseeable future. And Mexico demonstrated interest in Texas because it declared independence from Santa Anna's regime, not because we wanted it.
DeleteI think it is absolutely appalling what the US did to Mexico. The Manifest Destiny was definitely an excuse for America to expand its land and power. I agree with David M. Pletcher that it “...was also a justification, in that they wanted territory and needed an excuse or justification for a push into territory that they did not control. Although i think some part of it had to do with ideals, it was overshadowed by the prospect of gaining new land. This period in our history is not exactly a good time for us to look back on. We were ruthless and were more focused on war. We completely overlooked the treaty we signed with Mexico in 1828 which made us look even more of an aggressor.
ReplyDeleteI find the historian Velasco-Marquez to have a very interesting opinion regarding the war. He wrote, “ In conclusion, the armed conflict between Mexico and the United States from 1846 to 1848 was the product of deliberate aggression and should therefore be referred to as ‘The U.S. War Against Mexico.’” I do think the United States was the aggressors in the situation and should carry most of the blame, but I do think Mexico is a little at blame as well. They welcomed Americans into their land to try and increase their country. However, they were unable to sustain their government and in the end Texas wanted to annex itself. So I think the title, “The U.S. War Against Mexico’ is a bit harsh, but I can see where it comes from.
It seemed that Polk just wanted to start a war. He says, “There are other considerations important to the government and people of the United States, which incline me to believe that it would be far better that Mexico should declare a war now, than that it should propose to open negotiations for the settlement of pending differences…” Also, America was convinced it was a model for the rest of the world to follow. It had this romantic notion that it was it’s destiny to become a world leader. I completely disagree with Walt Whitman’s statement calling America for it to be its mission to expand into Mexican territory just because Mexico was less developed. I completely agree with Ulysses S. Grant referring to the U.S.-Mexican War as the “most unjust ever waged by a stronger against a weaker nation.”
I agree with what you're saying. A quote that really shows the type of aggression you are talking about is from the Mexican paper, El Tiempo that said , "The American government acted like a bandit who came upon a traveler." This is like how Mexico was a little at fault for opening up Texas, this is like being a traveler in this sense. And America, the bandit, took advantage of Mexico's vulnerable situation with the declaration of war. I agree when you say the Manifest Destiny was just a cover for more greedy motives. Americans had no right to fight for land they had no claim to. I don't agree when you say Polk just wanted to start a war. He did want to start a war but the main goal of the war was to gain land. He wanted land and American expansion and war at the time was the easiest way to achieve that.
DeleteThis comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteI do believe David Pletcher makes an excellent point as he says we were the ones that “attacked a neighbor”. It was fully the United States that wished to expand their territory and to complete this goal it was necessary for them to take the land of the Mexicans. The idea of Manifest Destiny was solely to justify their want for more land but it doesn’t not change the fact we started the attack. President Polk attempts to justify declaring war on Mexico by saying it is a national security issue at hand. I feel making statements such as these puts the blame more on the United States trying to cover up the facet they were looking for more land expansion. Mexico did not declare war as we see in, A Mexican Viewpoint on the War with the United States, “we find that war was never declared against the United States” on the United States. It was quite clear we had the upper hand in the situation seeing as Mexico did not have a strong military or government set up at the time. Mexico was very focused on maintaining the land they had among their people where as the United States just saw land available and a bit of a greedy need to expand our territory further. The intentions were not very good in comparison to Mexico. We clearly did not have much respect for the Mexican government and did not adhere to the arrangements we had already made in regards to the sovereignty of Texas. In one of the clips it discussed how American felt they had no limits at the time believe their destiny was to become a great power. There’s a difference that was not recognized of acting under the belief that will at one point become a powerful nation so it does not matter how we gain land, and gaining land out of determination. The idea of no limits is a bit disturbing to me at the time and comes off too confident for how a country should be.
ReplyDeleteAfter reading the articles and watching the video clips I see the United States as the aggressor in this war, and the idea of Manifest Destiny was its justification. People like Polk and Whitman used American expansion as a way to gain supporters and further this imperialistic mindset. The PBS video explained that many people referred to the war as “Mr. Polk’s War.” This video also explained how Thoreau opposed Polk’s decisions and he advised Americans to “follow their conscience.” Thoreau was an abolitionist and he recognized the injustices of Polk’s decision. Similarly, Ulysses S. Grant saw Manifest Destiny as a weak excuse for expansion. He fought in the U.S.-Mexican War and called it “one of the most unjust ever waged by a stronger against a weaker nation.” In my opinion, the idea of Manifest Destiny caused individuals to become greedy and selfish. People like Grant and Thoreau recognized the injustices that followed.
ReplyDeleteDavid Pletcher explains that Manifest Destiny “was also a justification, in that they wanted territory and needed an excuse or justification for a push into territory that they did not control.” That is what our country did during the Mexican-American war. Tindall and Shi explain how Polk manipulated the public during his war message. He declared that the war had been forced upon the United States after Mexicans attacked and killed eleven Americans. Polk’s main goal was to fight a war of force and expand U.S. territory. He used this situation to gain public support of the war further the ideas of American imperialism.
I found it interesting to read about a Mexican view point. Jesús Velasco-Márquez said, “U.S. historians refer to this event as “The Mexican War," while in Mexico we prefer to use the term "The U.S. Invasion." The U.S. was known for supporting freedoms and equality, yet the imperialistic greed for more land contradicted its ideals. David Pletcher explains, “The Americans did a great deal of talking and writing about liberty, but at the same time, they expanded the idea of Manifest Destiny. It was their destiny to expand across North America. The people poised in the way of that expansion, were aware of this, especially the Mexicans. “It is unfortunate that power and greed became the main focus for some Americans while our nation was founded on liberty and equality.
Overall, after reading more about Manifest Destiny and the U.S.-Mexican war I don’t believe the United States was justified in declaring war. These imperialistic ideas contradict the principles that Americans fought so hard to achieve. While people may use Manifest Destiny to justify why expansion would be good for America, I think it is a poor cover up for invading other nations without right.
Suz,
DeleteI liked how you included Polk's rousing of the American public into thinking this war was a good idea. While it may have seemed mischievous to foreign countries it must be remembered that Polk ran on a platform of geographic expansion. His provoking of the war was somewhat genius in achieving his goal of a larger America. He intelligently identified Mexico as a youthful nation that had inherited a huge amount of land from European powers that rendered them vulnerable. He worked the annexation of Texas in his quest to capture the economically valuable tracts of land in California and New Mexico, and Manifest Destiny was the nail on the coffin for his justification for starting a war that was seen positively by a vast majority of Americans.
This comment has been removed by the author.
DeleteWhile I agree that the US wasn't justified in invading Mexico, I think the problem is much more then manifest destiny was wrong. It was a flimsy argument, true, but there weren't all that many arguments against it. The war with mexico was wrong not because the idea of settling more land was wrong but because of how we went about it. I think Polk established how aggressive we were when he said, “I would not only march to the City of Mexico but I would pursue Santa Anna’s army wherever it was and capture or destroy it.” Clearly we weren't after just Texas or just California, we were seeking to assert dominance. here is where we really went wrong. if we had waited a little longer, perhaps negotiated more I think we could have gotten the land we wanted without the bloodshed.
DeleteAlthough the Mexican American war is primarily seen as American Expansionism, Imperialism, and aggression. the war itself was brought upon by both sides of the situation. The American identity developed into a country founded by Patriotism and a fighting spirit. An american pioneer once exclaimed, "If hell lay to the west, Americans would cross heaven to get there. The idea of Manifest Destiny was apparent and was the mindset of many Americans despite the belief that it was a justification for expansion, which is an argument that historian David M. Pletcher makes. However, the trend of the United States was already starting to move westward, and such events as the extension of boundaries in the War of 1812 and Louisiana Purchase were actions taken to satiate the desire of Americans to explore the frontier. Economic reasons are also not considered by Pletcher. The eastern seaboard was becoming crowded, property values were rising, and the political climate of the east was not particularly accepting of religious sects like Mormonism. Because of rapid urbanization and industrialization that formed in the east, their effects made life impossible for struggling craftsman or immigrants to the country. Heading west was taking a huge leap that held many dangers which was commonly known among those considering the risk. The westward expansion and Manifest Destiny were not simply justifications for entering a war over land with Mexico, it was an action taken in response to the rising tension because of geographic expansion.
ReplyDeleteWhen viewing the Mexican American war, the lens the conflict is seen through is influenced by American outlook. Jesús Velasco-Márquez and his point of view from the Mexican side of the war is just as important to understanding the event in its entirety. Velasco-Márquez took a road less traveled by American historians and explored the conditions of Mexico during the war as well as preceding it. Mexico was a juvenile nation that gained its independence through revolt to Spain and won. Because of this it was very hard for Mexico to argue against the independence claim of Texas. What also put the Mexican government in a precarious position before the war was some of the legislature that was passed, such as an article that prohibited the transfer of control of territories to another country. Essentially the government was stuck in between a rock and a hard place because of its inability to please the public without potentially starting a war with the United States. With the bullying from the United States through the threat of war, Mexico had no choice but to attempt to euthanize the ever-expanding beast of American expansionism.
From the very beginning of Poulk's campaign for presidency he ran on the the platform of western expansion into places like the mid-west an Oregon where he used manifest destiny and inherent rite of being a white american to take this land for yourself and live on it solely because of your existence and being. He had his opposition mainly abolitionists like Fredrick Douglas and later Thoreau who would see it as a ploy by southerners and Poulk a slave owner himself that his plans for western expansion would lead to more slave states a popular topic and would even grow further in fever as the years would pass until leading up to the civil war. To start with Mexico a nation just recently coming into fruition was plagued by instability and corruption ruled by a dictator santa anna who who was a deceitful liar and would be exiled multiple times but allowed back into the nation time and time again. Mexico had a vast amount of land that was once a property of Spain the boundaries of this land were clearly illustrated in the border treaty of 1828 and Texas and its inhabitants were part of that nation. Although Texas had set a constitution and would leave mexico if it were not meeting the needs that any uniform government possess which Mexico clearly didn't possess. They succeeded by themselves and beat back the Mexican forces but still didn't recognize their independence. American forces then signed a treaty with Texas and from Mexico's view that's illegal because it's an internal issue and the U.S. goes in and starts harassing this foreign nation to the point where they are attacking the capital and decimating the nation. In the end from how I look at it although at the time it may have been key to our nation shape today back then it was clear we were at fault for decimating this tiny fragile nation
ReplyDeleteIIt’s pretty much a given that Texas was free form Mexico (after all they used the same arguments that Mexico used against Spain and the US used against Britain) and annexing them hurt nothing but the feelings of Mexico (both the US and Texan legislative bodies agreed). However, the U.S. lost its moral hghgorund when it claimed the Rio Grande as a border and move in troops. To start with this action was a blatant attempt to bait Mexico towards war. Both Texas and Mexico had informally acknowledged the Nueces River as their border, to claim territory beyond that without any hint of negotiation was a blatantly aggressive move. Furthermore to move troops onto obviously disputed land was an intentional escalation of the bad feelings. Therefore, It was largely our fault (not entirely of course) that the dispute reached the point of war. As grant later stated, “We were sent to provoke a fight, but it was essential that Mexico commenced it.” I’ll admit that the Mexican government (what little of it there was ) acted rashly in attacking our troops, but staging a full fledged invasion in repose to a border skirmish wasn’t very fair either. If we truly believed in democracy (basically our argument for annexing Texas) we shouldn’t have taken advantage Mexico’s chaotic state
DeleteAt the same time I don’t agree with Thoreau and other antiwar voices like Quinsy Addams who believed the conflict was a massive southern conspiracy. To claim that the slaves slates orchestrate an entire war just to a few more seats in congress is a little bit of a stretch. Yes, slavery was advanced with the annexation, but I would say the flat out greed for land was more at fault and that was a view shared by northerners westerners and southerners.
While it’s all good and well to look back at the Mexican war and just blame it all on greed it its meaningless unless you look at it from the perspective of the times. Its obvious enough that the American people wanted to and were probably going to expand. Manifest destiny was moving and as flimsy as an argument as it was there weren’t all that many good reasons to stop it. American expansion across the northern continent (well up to Canada at least) was therefore understandable. Our annexation of Texas as I said before was also reasonable as both parties agreed. The same is true of California. So, as far as the expansionist mindset at the time, I find noting wrong with it. Land greed, however wrong it was and however responsible it was for the war, was not something you could simply fix. The problem came, however, when we purposefully pursued war with Mexico rather than using less aggressive means of getting the land we wanted. I’m not saying that negotiations would have definitely worked, but before we go and mobilize our army in disputed territory I think we should give them a little time to think. The worst that could happen is they invade Texas (giving us a justifiable right to respond) or everything boils down to a nonmilitary standoff (in which we win because Mexico doesn’t have much leverage when it comes to economic sections or overseas alliances). In the end they might get the territory between the Rio Grande and the Nueces (tough beans, oh well) and we might have to buy the land at a higher price but the point is we’re going to get most of land weather we provoke war and make them sign a treaty or not. Or, even if all this fails we could at least start a slightly smaller war, like perhaps not march all over Mexico and stage an amphibious landing just cause we can. Set up a couple of forts down by the border (maybe set up a fence or soothing) and bam problem solved. Sure they could attack but we already know we’re that leads, at least this way were not at fault for starting it. So in the end I agree most with Grant who regretted how the war was fought, though (if im correct) never really condemned the outcome
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDeleteAfter reading all of these sources and quotes, I can safely say that my opinion towards the Mexican-American War and who was responsible for it has completely been swayed. I am now completely in favor of the opinion that the U.S. was in the wrong. Through both modern historians and historical figures we finally see the view of the Mexicans, and the opposition in America, which are areas that were conveniently left out for the most part with the Tindall and Shi textbook.
ReplyDeleteTo start with the Mexican view on the war with United States. The article by Marquez states that there are three things that we commonly do not consider when discussing Mexico's involvement, "first, Mexico's internal state of affairs during the 1840s; second, the problem of Texas; and third, the U.S. invasion of Mexican territory". All three of these make perfect sense in context, and completely justify the actions taken by the Mexicans, while showing America's ruthlessness. The conflicting governments were something I thought of but never really applied to this situation. They were debating and bickering, because this was a new republic that they were unsure how to manage, and thus no one would want to think that peaceful regulations were the right thing, because it would be seen as weak. Then there is the matter with Texas, Marquez is completely right to say, "...the conflict was an internal problem. Let it be said in passing that Mexico's position was very similar to that adopted by the U.S. government when it faced the problem of the succession of its southern states years later". We were getting involved with a problem that was meant for Mexico and Mexico only.
Finally there was the fact that we instigated this by invading Mexico in the first place by having Taylor occupy the debated area in Mexico. This invasion was cruel way to force the Mexicans to keep fighting as shown in the El Tiempo quote, "...the Mexican government would not agree to such an excessive humiliation and a pretext would thus exist for resorting to war and for more cases of usurpation". Later on the United States would evolve with the idea that we were indeed acting cruelly. Figures such as Ulysses Grant and the modern historian David Pletcher alike both thought that this was the complete opposite of the ideals of democracy and freedom that we tried to impose, and was instead just an aggressive way to obtain certain means.
I agree with a lot that has already been said. The American public’s idea of Manifest Destiny was, according to Tindal and Shi, “a cluster of flimsy rationalizations for naked greed and imperial ambition” (343). As a fairly new country, America was itching to expand. People had been traveling west in an effort to acquire new lands and make it rich. This spirit of adventure and exploration is natural and understandable. However, ambition led Americans into a slippery slope of entitlement where they felt they had this “God given right” to push people out of their land and use violence to promote their quest for wealth and land.
ReplyDeleteThey masked this entitlement with the term Manifest Destiny, which was devastating to Mexico. Polk argued that the Mexican War was a war of self defense. I completely disagree with this statement. Tensions were already high between the two nations because of the annexation of Texas and America provoked the war even further by placing troops on the Mexican border. Mexico had no desire in the beginning to go to war in the beginning. Manuel de la Peña y Peña, foreign relations minister of Mexico wanted to, “settle the current dispute in a peaceful, reasonable and respectable way.” This sentiment ended, with good cause when the Americans persisted to harass Mexico and they felt the need to resort to violence.
One of the most powerful opinions I thought was from the El Republicano that stated, “a government...that starts a war without a legitimate motive is responsible for all its evils and horrors. The bloodshed, the grief of families, the pillaging, the destruction, the violence, the fires, and its works and its crimes...Such is the case of the U.S. Government, for having initiated the unjust war it is waging against us today.” The only motive for war was a greedy quest for land, resources, and money. Thousands of lives were lost in this war on both sides and it was truly a tragedy on that accord. However, it did allow for a growth of American enterprise and influence which has formed the country we live in today. Maybe the person I agree with most is Ralph Waldo Emerson who disliked the war but then proclaimed, “Most of the great results of history are brought about by discreditable means” (Tindal and Shi, 463).
I agree Cori, Polks argument that the Mexican War was a war of self-defense is weak. Many people, including Walt Whitman believed, in a certain sense, that Mexico was inferior to the U.S. Whitman says, "What has miserable, inefficient Mexico—with her superstition, her burlesque upon freedom, her actual tyranny by the few over the many—what has she to do with the great mission of peopling the new world with a noble race? Be it ours, to achieve that mission!" Clearly, Whitman was not the only person who claimed these opinions. Their are so many ulterior motives associated with westward expansion that are neatly and unethically justified by manifest destiny. These motives include: land expansion, expansion of slavery, and the expansion of the market.
DeleteI completely agree with historian David M. Pletcher in that “Manifest Destiny” was an excuse for the citizens of the U.S. to march over and take land that was not rightfully theirs. That aside I do believe that the decision was a product of the time and the people cannot be blamed for coming to war as a logical conclusion to their plans of a U.S. with the Rio as its southern border. They are exactly the hypocrites that Pletcher states them to be, however it takes two to tango. The Mexicans may not have been the aggressor that America was, but they fell for the trap due to their anger. Jesús Velasco-Márquez for this reason in my mind is wrong in solely blaming the U.S. for the war. I find it hard to believe that Mexico would participate in a war without some ulterior motive behind the war. Yes the U.S. was attacking Mexican land, but pitting all the blame on them is foolish.
ReplyDeleteNo person better understands the war in my opinion than Ulysses S. Grant who stated that; We were sent to provoke a fight, but it was essential that Mexico commence it.” The war as I have stated is a two part conflict and though peace was out of the question blame can be put on both. It is the responsibility of both sides to do all they can in order to keep peace and in the case of Mexico peace was not worth as much if little effort was given to it. People in modern day will always be able to look back on the mistakes of this war and point out the flaws. This is because they are looking at it from the modern viewpoint which puts the U.S. at fault and the war as a stupid endeavor. However at the time it was a sane and effective solution for the acquisition of the lands. Blood may have been spilled, but if every drop is worth the land that is in question people will line up to fight. That was the logic that surrounded the whole war and I can say that I firmly believe had I lived during the time the war probably would have seemed reasonable yet not just.
If any of the U.S. actions were just it was the acquisition of Texas which had been acquired through more legal means than the rest. I believe that the Texans had the thought of becoming American citizens and had grown to value the democracy which they obtained in America, and wanted in the west. To achieve this they needed to escape the jurisdiction of Santa Anna. For America to take them in was reasonable, and the Mexican attack made Mexico seem an aggressor. However the acquisition of New Mexico was in no means justified. Mexico and it’s people had laid claim to it in people and the reality was that while liberty was more at work in Texas, “Manifest Destiny” was at work elsewhere.
I enjoyed the fact that you took a step back from the articles we read and wanted to think about whether or not the United States was entirely at fault. I'll admit the articles and quotes definitely convinced me of the United States as the villain. However, you make some good arguments about the legality of the acquisition of Texas and that Mexico was the one who actually commenced the fight which the United States might have provoked. I would like to disagree though that I still believe that the Mexicans would have been humiliated and seen as dependent on the United States if they had done anything but went to war with them. Thus, I don't think they had a choice in whether or not they should commence fighting. Overall though, you had an interesting point of view that I didn't consider, good job!
DeleteThe Mexican-American War is too complex an issue to pinned on one party; however, the larger share of blame should be placed on the United States. After all, it was President Polk who instigated the conflict with Mexico and gave flawed rationale as to why we should pursue this conquest. In this debate, I completely align myself with Grant.
ReplyDeletePolk's argument is founded on the idea of "Manifest Destiny". Manifest Destiny was widely interpreted, but at its very core, it was the notion that the United States of American was fated to control North America. Despite being newcomers, Americans believed that they were the rightful heirs of North America and were entitled to all of continent's land. There was incredible patriotic light shed on this movement, obscured the glaring imperialism and racism. Using Manifest Destiny as justification, Anglo-Saxon Americans were able to undermine existing Mexican and Indian authorities.
Walt Whitman, a poet who sided with the likes of Polk, tried to clear his party of blame. In Brooklyn Daily Eagle Editorial from 1846, he defends, "What has miserable, inefficient Mexico - with her superstition, her burlesque upon freedom, her actual tyranny by the few over the many - what has she to do with the great mission of peopling the New World with a noble race? Be it ours, to achieve that mission!" In this statement, Whitman is essentially claiming that Mexicans are simply incapable of carrying out the freedoms of an American democracy. He alleges that since the Mexican people do not have the same rights as Americans, it is America's "noble" conquest to liberate them from "her [Mexico's] actual tyranny." Although Whitman and Polk sound very honorable, they are just veiling their true motives with the popular Manifest Destiny.
Historian David Pletcher puts it concisely when he writes, "The Americans did a great deal of talking and writing about liberty, but at the same time, they expanded the idea of Manifest Destiny." The usurpation associated with Manifest Destiny greatly contrast the American ideal liberty. The United States failed to respect Mexico's sovereignty, which is pretty ironic since they, like Mexico, had broken away from their motherland and weren't originally seen as legitimate. Instead of finding solace in their similar origins, the United States unnecessarily asserts its dominance over the infant nation as a power move. Despite the hypocrisy, the United States doesn't waver when agitating Mexico. Reflecting on the war years later, General Ulysses S. Grant remarks, “one of the most unjust ever waged by a stronger against a weaker nation.” Although disillusioned at the time, Grant's words still ring true today.
I think it's really interesting that you align yourself on Grant's position on the Mexican War. Grant once said, "I do not think there ever was a more wicked war than that waged by the United States in Mexico. I thought so at the time, when I was a youngster, only I had not moral courage enough to resign." This notes a refreshing and sympathetic view of Grant, who didn't necessarily agree with the ideals that were driving the war. However, I cannot fully support Grant and give him too much credit for exactly the reason he stated; he confessed his regret lack of courage to stand for his beliefs.
DeleteI believe that justifying the Mexican-American war is not as black and white as some historians and contemporaries of the time make it out to be. To be clear, there is no doubt in my mind that the United States and James Polk provoked the war. This is rather clear when you consider how the war was started. Mexico did attempt negotiations with the U.S. in order to try to avoid a conflict, although Slidell and the U.S. were not very willing to budge. Polk also sent General Taylor to secure positions along the Rio Grande, which he knew would provoke Mexican retaliation. Not to mention this action was in violation of the 1828 border treaty. Mexico had also previously stated that the annexation of Texas would be considered an act of war, even before it was officially carried through by the U.S. government. Polk knew exactly what he was getting himself into when he sent Taylor to secure positions along the Rio Grande. He then used the ensuing Mexican retaliation as a way to justify starting the war, and getting congress and the senate to approve it. The war was clearly provoked by the U.S. in an attempt to fulfill their "manifest destiny" to govern over the land that Providence had rightfully provided them. For these reasons it is easy to see why so many saw the war as being unjust, including Ulysses S. Grant, later in his life. The war was also seen as an attempt to add more slave holding states in the Union, but that motive was not held universally by supporters of the war. Outside countries did not seem to buy into this idea of manifest destiny either, as many Europeans saw the U.S. as hypocritical, and lacked respect for their actions.
ReplyDeleteThe truth is, however, that many, in fact most, Americans were in support the war and expanding westward. Views have evidently changed, and the war is considered an unjust one generally today, however, it is not that simple. The reason that I believe the war is not as black and white as it is made out to be has to do with Mexico's status as a country at the time. Mexico was not a very stable country. Power shifted often between different leaders, including Santa Anna and Herrera leading up to the war. The government in Mexico was not stable at the time, and they had many of their own domestic issues to worry about. Besides this, in 1823 Mexico actually started encouraging American settlers to come into Texas. Evidently, their encouragement worked, because in 1835 there were 10 times as many Americans in Texas as there were Mexicans. Mexico encouraged Americans to come into Texas until they were extremely outnumbered, and once America wanted Texas, Mexico did not want the U.S. to have anything to do with Texas. In fact, Mexico was even going to let Texas secede, but not be annexed by the United States. Despite the U.S. provoking war, Mexico also did not budge on their insistence that Texas did not join the U.S. By the time war started, it was impractical for Mexico to fight for Texas. The majority of people living in Texas were not even Mexican and naturally would rather be a part of the United States. Mexico had allowed too many Americans to settle Texas, and had far too unstable of a government to have a completely legitimate claim over Texas.
I agree with the statements you made about America's initiation of the war as well as your argument that the claim over Texas by the United States was justified. The Mexicans didn't create enough resistance against Texas's succession and didn't really have control over the outcome. The United States really didn't have a justification to fight over the territory other than the idea that America's destiny was the territory of the Continent. Although, the United States did urge Texas to delcare independence and contributed volunteers to their cause. There were many Americans fighting for the independence of Texas and this makes the intentions clear. There was an element of aggressiveness in attempts to secure more land, but Mexico didn't have the resources, organization, or leadership to stop it.
DeleteSpeaking of David Pletcher, his article gives the other area that Tindall and Shi could have spent more time expressing. This is the opposition that other people including America had towards the war, unlike the opinion of the Mexicans, these opinions haven't evolved considerably, because they are reasons that we still accept today as possible causes for opposition by people in this time period. Opposition mainly came through the motives that were used for this war. The primary motive was to annex territory from Mexico, in other words, expand, however not everyone was on board with the idea of expansion. Some citizens believed that The United States' form of self-government would not work in such a large area. Pletcher and even Tindall and Shi also stated that, "...the Northeast and East Coast felt they would lose power if the United States admitted more states in to the Union" which may sound a bit selfish, does make sense at the time since some might say the northeast was considered the birthplace of the country. European countries also saw the United States as hypocritical, in having ideals of freedom, but seek land expansion.
ReplyDeleteThe other popular reason for opposition which makes quite a lot of sense at the time was the opposition concerning the expansion of slavery. Abolitionists have every right to believe that a new state admitted, especially in the southwest, would become a slave state. Henry David Throeau in his essay, Uncivil Disobedience wrote, "I think it is not too soon for honest men to rebel and revolutionize, this people must cease to hold slaves, and make war on Mexico". I am completely in agreement with the skepticism that some citizens should have had about expansion, and the fact the United States was indeed being a bit hypocritical. I am also most definitely in agreement with the idea that this war will only accomplish the extension of slavery.
Tindall and Shi makes brief mentions of opposition against the war in America, but not nearly as much as the articles given to us here. Instead the book spends more time talking about the battles themselves, and the atrocities committed by the Mexicans, specifically Santa Anna who for example slayed Americans at the Alamo and, "ordered the wounded Americans put to death and their bodies burned with the rest". True, while one Mexican may have caused a cruel event like that, we forget who really instigated the war, and who was really victimized. Polk has no good arguments either. He claimed that Mexico, "had crossed over the U.S. border, had invaded our territory and had cawed the shedding of U.S. blood in U.S. territory". When in fact he ordered Taylor to cross into what was technically Mexican territory across the Nueces River. Polk argued that those in opposition were going against patriotism and that there was no other alternative. When in fact Polk was going against basic patriotic ideals of liberty by invading Mexico, and there was in fact still the alternative of peaceful negotiations which would have avoided bloodshed. Through the points of opposition by the Americans both at the time as well as today, along with cruel treatment of the Mexicans, I can safely say I agree with arguments made by these historians.
Manifest destiny was perceived in the mid nineteenth century as a pure American ideal. Historian David M. Pletcher of Indiana University remarks that, “manifest destiny was a conviction that God intended North America to be under the control of Americans.” This ideal got the attention of the American people as, essentially, a way to extend American democracy to the rest of the country. It has been argued, however, that the underlying motives of westward expansion are justified by this ideal Manifest Destiny. In reality, many argue, that sectionalist motives, such as the slave interests of the south, the industrial interests of the north, the land hunger of the west, were the real reasons Americans wanted westward expansion.
ReplyDeleteDuring the mid-nineteenth century, contemporary thinkers such as Henry David Thoreau opposed the popular idea of manifest destiny and therefore support for the Mexican War. In fact, Thoreau refused to pay taxes to support the war, and was, subsequently, thrown in prison. He protested against the support of the war effort because he thought it was simply a way to expand slave territory. This greatly contrasted with thinkers like Walt Whitman who said in regards to the Mexican War, "We love to indulge in thoughts of the future extent and power of this Republic - because with its increase is the increase of human happiness and liberty. . . . What has miserable, inefficient Mexico - with her superstition, her burlesque upon freedom, her actual tyranny by the few over the many - what has she to do with the great mission of peopling the New World with a noble race? Be it ours, to achieve that mission!" Whitman, like many other Americans believed in this idea of “increasing human happiness and liberty,” in a sense imposing such values), on countries like Mexico. This connects to the idea that manifest destiny was a way to extend American democracy, among other reasons.
In turn, historians looking back on the Mexican war show that interpretations have indeed evolved over time. Historians like Pletcher ultimately view that Mexican War as a war of aggression between the U.S. and Mexico. Pletcher explains, “It's a kind of early projection of Anglo-saxon supremacy and there's a racist element to it.” So in a sense, historians like Pletcher would more likely agree with Thoreau and argue that American motives for westward expansion were less than noble, but rather fed into a desire to satisfy their own section’s self-interest (slavery, land owning, and increased economic potential). This quote also connects to highlight a criticism in Whitman’s view of the Mexican war: a sense of supremacy America has over others.
I disagree with the idea that "Manifest Destiny", as David Pletcher put it, had a racist element or an Anglo-Saxon supremacy. There was no intention of these things. There was no intention of supremacy of the Natives. The view was completely nationalistic. People had an overwhelming feeling of Americanism that fueled them to have this possession over the continent. The citizens of the United States were overwhelmed with the success of their new country. Exploration and providing for the American cause was the goal.
ReplyDeleteThe American people needed to expand in order to live. There was a lack of space and jobs in the Northeast so people took initiative. It is doubtful that there was a supremacy complex in most of the minds traveling along the Overland trail. People were just looking for a better life. It was inevitable that these mainly wild and unsettled lands were eventually going to be settled by Americans or some other country.
However I do agree that there was a great deal of hypocrisy that went along with the "Manifest Destiny". David Pletcher makes the point that Americans were constantly preeching about liberty and the spread of liberty to other countries. Yet, the expand and include slavery in the state (Texas) they have admitted. Not only was slavery hypocritical, but their treatment of the Indians was outrageous. They enslaved Indians in California and put them to work. The Natives' prosperity and "pursuit of happiness" was destroyed by the intrusive expansion of American lands, diseases, and shared resources (Buffalo). The Mexicans were also taken advantage of because they had a right to this land that the Americans violated.
The interpretations of the Mexican-American War has evolved significantly. Mainly because presently we view this war with a completely different mind set. Americans in the mid-1800s saw expansion and the war as a justified improvement. Now all historians can see today is a greedy and selfish decision.
I think this is what the general modern day viewed has shifted to. It’s hard to condemn a war that has brought us so much (basically a third of America if you count California and all the south west) yet at the same time we regret how we went about it. so while we can’t change what we did I think we could learn a lesson about getting involved in other wars… somewhere with lots of oil and possible WMDs perhaps.
ReplyDeleteToday Texas is an economic powerhouse for the United States, so looking at this scenario from the Mexican perspective during the mid-nineteenth century along with my modern perspective of course I wouldn't want Texas to become an independent republic or go back to the sovereignty of the Mexican Republic. However, Velasco-Marquez presents a very good argument. I cannot look past the fact that the U.S., by adding Texas, would be completely ignoring the 1828 border treaty that it had with Mexico. This action would also be ignoring international law (although the specifics of this I'm not quite sure of), not to mention disregarding the principles set forth in the Monroe Doctrine years before. Another thing I didn't before consider is that Mexico does not call this conflict "The Mexican War," but rather "U.S. Invasion." Velasco-Marquez also points out a good point about Polk: that he blamed Mexico for starting the war. Finger-pointing is never effective in an issue as complicated and as large-scale as this and it speaks negatively to the presidency of Polk and therefore his entire administration. For the most part, I found this historian's points very relevant and convincing, but afterwards I was left thinking about Texas' perspective. I would like to gain a better understanding of the position of Texas in this mess - were they actually more drawn to the United States? Or was that just a result of politicians? Maybe the majority of those living in Texas were not well represented and actually preferred return to the sovereignty of Mexico.
ReplyDeleteThe points made by Pletcher in the first reading further increase my support for Mexico. He points out how the whole idea of Manifest Destiny that came about during this time period was simply a justification for the desire to expand westward and occupy land that was not rightfully the United States'. Some Americans were idealistic in their thinking - that the United States had the God-given right to expand westward - but the arguments of the contemporaries of the time (Grant, Thoreau and Whitman) that were against the idea of Manifest Destiny highlight the truth in a time of false conceptions.
However, although these outspoken contemporaries of the time were very correct in speaking out against those so inclined by the idea of manifest destiny, they were not well-received enough. The U.S. still waged a war against Mexico because this new idea was so popular. It overpowered all other morals that may have driven the U.S. back from the battle front. It was a time of American egotism and expression of Anglo-saxon supremacy, but when it was occurring it was viewed by so many as a necessity for a country that was destined by God to spread its form of democracy across all of North America. Today we see the fallacy and the hypocrisy and we recognize the validity of Mexico's standpoint in this predicament, unlike almost two hundred years ago when our nation's ego prevailed.